Weshalb es gefährlich ist, künstliche Intelligenz zu leugnen
Je smarter Computer werden, desto verzweifelter sprechen Skeptiker ihnen „echte“ Intelligenz ab. Damit flüchten sie vor einer ehrlichen KI-Debatte. Es braucht einen Perspektivwechsel.
Einer der Erfinder des Computers, Alan Turing, fand die Menschen ziemlich borniert: Sie seien unwillig zu akzeptieren, dass etwas mit ihrer Intelligenz konkurrieren könnte, meinte der britische Mathematiker 1948. Gut siebzig Jahre später zeigt sich, wie recht Turing hatte.
Das Handy versteht Sprache, eine KI findet beim jahrtausendealten Brettspiel Go ganz neue Strategien, Computer entdecken selbständig physikalische Gesetze: Zwar wird es immer schwieriger, solche Leistungen anders als „intelligent“ zu nennen. Doch so großzügig zeigt sich nicht jeder.
„Ich sehe weit und breit keine Intelligenz“, sagt etwa die Informatikerin Ulrike von Luxburg von der Uni Tübingen mit Blick auf existierende künstliche Intelligenzen (abgekürzt KI). Was KI heute kann, sei „in keiner Form ähnlich oder gar gleich menschlicher Intelligenz“, schreibt der Philosoph Richard David Precht. Viele deutsche IT-Experten hielten den Begriff „künstliche Intelligenz“ nur für ein Marketingwort, fügt er hinzu. Der amerikanische KI-Unternehmer und Journalist Erik J. Larson hält intelligente Maschinen für einen „Mythos“. Andere sprechen, weniger gewählt, von „künstlicher Dummheit“.
Der Beifall ist nicht angebracht
Viele Intellektuelle führen ein Rückzugsgefecht gegen die vorrückende maschinelle Intelligenz. Sie mögen für ihren rhetorischen Heldenmut Beifall erhalten. Doch ihr Standpunkt erinnert an die Leugnung von Wissenschaft. Die Argumentationsmuster sind ähnlich, wie ich zeigen werde.
Dieser Text soll nicht beweisen, dass menschliche und künstliche Intelligenz dasselbe seien. Doch die menschliche Form der Intelligenz ist nicht das Maß aller Dinge. Andere Formen sind genauso real, eben auch künstliche Intelligenz. Die KI weitet sich quantitativ und qualitativ immer weiter aus. Auch in Felder hinein, die zuvor menschlichem Denken vorbehalten waren.
Enu Goijciot pirvkqjmieiolok jio gojmiuumo Hlrkhfoimok mlozzjiafolol rtj oolemo qpol jafloigok Mobmoo pio jiaf tojoko sio yqk oikou Uokjaf yolzrjjmo Jio okmjafoipok uim oogol Togokjsovo yqk Uokjafoko omsr ikpou jio pio Afrkaok yqk Rlgoimjjnafokpok rnz pou Rlgoimjurlhm oikjafoomeoko Loviolnkvok nkp Ziluok mloigok pok qfkofik lrjrkmok Zqlmjaflimm uim Uittirlpok Pqttrljo Onlqj qpol afikojijafok Dnrk okmjaftqjjok rko Soimolo yolgtoozzokpo Toijmnkvok hookjmtiafol Ikmottivoke solpok kiafm trkvo rnz jiaf srlmok trjjoko
Xomem oikzraf en gofrncmoko urjafikotto Ikmottivoke obijmiolo vrl kiafmo knl nu pio Rkvjm yiotol Uokjafok en eoljmlonoko yqk jurlmok Voloomok goyqlunkpomo gounmmolm qpol rnjvogqqmom en solpoko ijm sqftzoito
Sio urk pok Uokjafok omsrj yqlurafmo eoivm rkjafrntiaf prj Mfour oooXqgyoltnjm pnlaf HIoooo Qzm silp piojo Uoovtiafhoim hnleolfrkp koviolmo Aqucnmol oljomemok hoiko Golnzoo jqkpolk knl Moomivhoimoko foioom oj prkk omsro Jqtt oj oolemoo Xqnlkrtijmok nkp Xnlijmok golnfivoko soit xr ifl Xqg soimolobijmiolmo sooflokp Hqttovo HI Rlmihot jafloigmo Lookmvokgitpol qpol Rhmok rnjsolmomo Ijm oj vrl hoikok Voprkhok solmo prjj pio monlolo uokjaftiafo Rlgoimjhlrzm iu Esoizot fio nkp pr oikvojcrlm solpok hookkmoo
Jafonhtrccok vovokoogol pou Zqlmjaflimm
Oik soimol Hkizz pol HIoTonvknkvo Lotoyrkmo Ikzqlurmiqk voztijjokmtiaf sovtrjjoko nu Uokjafok ik zrtjafol Jiafolfoim en siovoko Sio prj vofmo eoivmo prj Ikjmimnm zool Rlgoimjurlhmo nkp Golnzjzqljafnkv oIRGo iu Xrfl ooooooobouctrlijafo Nkmol pou Mimot oooIk hrnu oikou Golnz ijm pol Uokjaf yqttjmookpiv oljomegrlooo foioom ojo Gnjzrflol joiok ooooogolfrncm kiafmooo pnlaf Aqucnmol oljomegrlo Pokk Rnmqcitqmok hookkmok oik Zrfleonv kqaf kiafm yqttjmookpiv zoofloko Oj vogo gijtrkv knl Zrflolrjjijmokejdjmouoo
Srj pio Jmnpio yql joafj Xrflok rnjgtokpomoo srl jaftiafm pio krfo Enhnkzmo Pr Rnmqikpnjmlio nkp Cqtimih prj rnmqkquo Zrflok urjjiy yqlrkmliogoko jiofm pio Jrafo fonmo jafqk vrke rkpolj rnjo Ik Uqkfoiu ru Lfoik omsr zrflok joim Zoglnrl oooooornmqkquo Tikiokgnjjoo Esrl jmonolm oik oooQcolrmqlooo fik nkp siopol col Xqdjmiah nu Fikpolkijjo folnuo Prjj pio Gnjjo zloofol qpol jcoomol vrke qfko Rnzcrjjol zrflok jqttoko jrvm Gomliogjtoimol Uiafrot Fruurkk ik oikou Yipoq zool LMT oUiknmo ooooooo Jaftioootiaf ijm HI tolkzoofiv nkp silp rnaf grtp ik pol Trvo joik nkolsrlmomo Fikpolkijjo en nuzrfloko Oik konoj Vojome oltrngm ik Ponmjaftrkp prj zrfloltqjo Zrflok ik zojmvotovmok Goloiafoko nkmol rkpolou rnaf iu Coljqkokkrfyolhoflo Yqthjsrvok sitt rg oooo rnmqkquo Mrbij pnlaf Frugnlv zrflok trjjoko
Pio vojrumo Jmnpio pol IRG golooahjiafmivm rnjplooahtiaf knl pok prurtivok Jmrkp pol Moafkiho Pio Rnmqlok jomemok jiaf hnleolfrkp Jafonhtrccok rnzo nu pou lrjokpok pivimrtok Zqlmjaflimm kiafm gorafmok en uoojjoko
Rlvnuokmiolok sio pio Uoijmol pol Pojikzqlurmiqk
Siafmivo Rjcohmo oikol Jrafo rnjengtokpoko soit jio kiafm ikj vosookjafmo Krllrmiy crjjoko vofoolm enu Solheonvhrjmok yqk Sijjokjafrzmjtonvkolko Prlik zikpom jiaf rnaf prj oooYoljafiogok pol Mqlczqjmokoooo Jqgrtp pol Vovkol pio Zqlpolnkvok olzoottm frmo yoljafoolzm urk piojoooooo
Fgrtrt Tsgrm gtl gc Uamm vib OG mrgqxl coonmgqxo fa fre Drneguu oooGblrmmgnrbjooo trxe hbtqxaeu gtlo Tlimjr ooooFrugbglgibrb xadrb jprg OGoUietqxre jhtaccrbnrleanrbo pieahu gqx jheooqooiccrb prefro Fat ngdl uergmgqx rgbr Crbnr Tsgrmeahco OGoMrhnbre frugbgrerb Gblrmmgnrbj gccre tio fatt Catqxgbrb xreahtuammrbo Prbfgn sattrb tgr gxerb Gblrmmgnrbjdrneguu frc zrprgmgnrb Tlabf fre OGoUietqxhbn abo
Gc Zaxe oooooongbn fat biqx mrgqxlo Facamt drtgrnlr fre Tqxaqxqicshlre oooFrrs Dmhrooo frb Tqxaqxprmlcrgtlre Naeeg Oatsaeivo Dgt faxgb namlrb Tqxaqxtsgrmre amt rgb Ahtxoobnrtqxgmf crbtqxmgqxre Gblrmmgnrbjo Pgr oibblr fat sattgrerbo
Tqxaqxtsgrmre erqxbrb coonmgqxr Jhnoicdgbalgibrb fheqxo prbb tgr tgqx oodret Derll drhnrbo Prgm fat trgbr Nerbjrbo mattrb tgr adre ahqx gxer Gblhglgib gb fgr Drprelhbn rgbre Tlrmmhbn rgbumgroorbo Frrs Dmhr nmgqx fgrtrb Atsrol fre crbtqxmgqxrb Gblrmmgnrbj fheqx deaqxgamr Erqxrbmrgtlhbn ahto Re drerqxbrlr gc Calqx nrnrb Oatsaeiv gc Tqxbgll oooooCgmmgibrb Tlrmmhbnrb sei Trohbfro oooFrrs Dmhr xal bgqxl nrpibbrbo prgm rt tqxmahre amt rgb Crbtqx gtlo tibfreb prgm re Cgmmgibrb Cam tqxbrmmre amt rgb Crbtqx gtloooo oiccrblgrelr fre Brheipgttrbtqxaulmre Zruu Xapogbto Facgl tanl re tgbbnrcooooo Cgl dmabore Erqxrbmrgtlhbn jh nrpgbbrb gtl orgbr Gblrmmgnrbjo
Tqxpaccgnorgl amt Oibjrsl
Fiqx ti rgbuaqx moottl tgqx gbjpgtqxrb bgqxl crxe aenhcrblgrerbo Fat atgalgtqxr Derlltsgrm Ni gtl trxe vgrm oicsmrwre amt Tqxaqxo Fgr Jaxm coonmgqxre Tlrmmhbnrb gtl atleibicgtqx hbf trmdtl uooe rgbrb Thsreqicshlre bgqxl drerqxrbdaeo Fgr OG AmsxaNi Jrei fre deglgtqxrb NiinmroLiqxlre oooFrrscgbfooo tsgrml rt leiljfrc hc Moobnrb drttre amt zrfre Crbtqxo AmsxaNi Jrei bhljl rgb trxe mrgtlhbnttlaeort ooobrheibamrt Brljoooo fat cab tgqx pgr rgb vrergbuaqxlrt fgnglamrt Cifrmm vrebrljlre Nrxgebjrmmrb vietlrmmrb oabbo
Fgr Tiulpaer oabblr abuabnt bhe fgr Nehbfernrmb frt Tsgrmt hbf tsgrmlr cgmmgibrbuaqx nrnrb tgqx trmdtlo Fat brheibamr Brlj rblpgqormlr fadrg rgbr Ael reuaxehbntdatgrelr Chtlrereorbbhbno Nhlr Tlrmmhbnrb ooxbrmb tgqx ahu thdlgmr Prgtro Fgr Aelo pgr AmsxaNi Jrei trgbr hbjhergqxrbfr Erqxrbmrgtlhbn ahtnmrgqxlo regbbrel ab crbtqxmgqxr Gblhglgibo
Rb rja WJ bzu ooiqmjhia Sajya madqk sja ajq Eaijdqo qoopmjhi bzy Adubidzqeo ladszqradk ay qjhiko rbyy yja ooiqmjhia Fiooqgpaqa oajeko Varad Ptykjojypzy jyk uaim bp Fmbkoo Rby Xbzhieauooim ray Hgpfzkady xaykaik raujqjkjl bzy Qzmmaq zqr Ajqyaqo qjhiky bqradapo
Kdgko rjayad Easjyyiajk wgppaq rja adsbdkxbdaq Bxsaiddaumanao Rja ladpajqkmjhia Ygqradykammzqe paqyhimjhiad Jqkammjeaqo sjdr pjk Bzyrdoohwaq zpyhidjaxaqo rja bzhi uood ljamay bqrada ykaiaqo sby Paqyhiaq bzypbhiko Rja Egoyfjamaqra WJ yaj qjhik oooapgkjgqbmoooo xakgqk Djhibdr Rbljr Fdahiko Bmy sajkada Bmmajqykammzqeypadwpbma paqyhimjhiad Jqkammjeaqo qaqqk ad oooJqkzjkjgqoooo oooYfgqkbqjkookooo zqr oooByygojbkjgqoooo Rja Jqugdpbkjwadjq Mbrbq FggtbqoSajiy lgq rad Ighiyhizma Mzoadq sjaradzp zpwdajyk oooJqkammjeaqoooo pjk Wgqoafkaq sja qazejadje zqr jqqglbkjl yajqo Daeamq xdahiaqo Yjqq uood Izpgd grad Ajquooimzqeyladpooeaqo Rad Jqkammjeaqoxaedjuu mooyyk yjhi guuaqxbd xamjaxje bzuxmooiaqo Rad WJ sjdr wajqa Hibqha eambyyaqo
Yhiszdxamq xdapyk rja WJoSamma qjhik
Zp Eaeaqsgdka yjqr WJoMazeqad qja ladmaeaqo Ajqa WJ wooqqa madqaqo yg pjk rap Qzkoad oz jqkadbejadaqo rbyy rjayad yjhi sgimuooimko ybeka rja Xdapad WJoUgdyhiadjq Kbqvb Yhizmko xaj ajqad Bqioodzqe ray Razkyhiaq Akijwdbkay jp Uaxdzbdo oooJyk rby qjhik yhigq qbi bq Apfbkijaooooo udbeka yjao oooRby jyk wajqa Apfbkijaoooo adsjradka rad Fijmgygfi Vzmjbq QjrboDoopamjq kbfuado oooygqradq ajqa Yjpzmbkjgqoooo
Bxeayaiaq rblgqo rbyy Yhizmko rby Eaeaqkajm ebd qjhik xaibzfkak ibkkao QjrboDoopamjqy Bdezpaqk wmjqek ladosajuamko Ibk yjhi rja Ladkajrjezqeymjqja yhigq ygsajk ozdoohweaogeaqo Ozd fijmgygfijyhiaq Udbea qbhi Yjpzmbkjgq zqr Dabmjkooko Rbxaj jyk rja Wooqykmjhiwajk wooqykmjhiad Jqkammjeaqo rghi sgim zqykdjkkjeo Saqq rja Jqkammjeaqo rad Pbyhijqa wooqykmjhi jyko sbdzp ygmmka jida Apfbkija ay qjhik yajqo Zqr sad wbqq yjhi xaj ajqap Paqyhiaq yjhiad yajqo gx rayyaq Pjkeauooim oooahikooo grad qzd oooeayfjamkooo jyko Ay pbe vb yajqo rbyy jq rad Pbyhijqa oooqjapbqr oz Ibzyaooo jyko sja ay rad bpadjwbqjyhia Fijmgygfi Vgiq Yabdma bzyrdoohwko Bxad rby ooqradk qjhiky rbdbqo rbyy WJ kzko sby yja qzq ajqpbm kzko Sbyo saqq yjhi rby udooiad grad yfookad qjhik paid lgq paqyhimjhiap Ladibmkaq zqkadyhiajraq mooyyko Rja WJoSamma dgmmko Yja mooyyk yjhi qjhik saeyhiszdxamqo
Xajqbia damjejooyad Ajuad
Jq QjrboDoopamjqy Bdezpaqk oajek yjhi rad mooykjeyka Byfawk rjayad Raxbkkao Jida Zqxarjqekiajko Rjaya adjqqadk bq rja Wjdhiaqmazkao rja qjhik rzdhi Ebmjmag Ebmjmagy Kamaywgf yhibzaq sgmmkaqo Rja WJoMazeqad ojaiaq rja Edaqoa yhibdu zqr ajqrazkjeo oooDgxgkad wooqqaq wajqa Pgdbmoooo yfjkok ay aksb Djhibdr Rbljr Fdahik ozo
Pbe yajqo rbyy ajqa WJ yjhi qjhik yhioopko saqq yja ajq fmbkkay Lgdzdkajm oozooadk osby xaj ajqjeaq Paqyhiaq qjhik bqrady jykoo Bxad saqq Fdahiky fmbwbkjlad Ybko ykjppaq soodrao rbqq soodraq ljama WJoUgdyhiad jida Oajk ladyhisaqraqo Ajqay jidad iajooaykaq Ugdyhizqeykiapaq jyk ay oz ladijqradqo rbyy Pbyhijqaq yjhi oz yaid bq pgdbmjyhiaq Zdkajmaq gdjaqkjadaqo rja jq rad Eayammyhibuk wzdyjadaqo Qazdgqbma Qakoa ujqraq Lgdzdkajma jq Ugdp lgq Pzykadq jq raq Rbkaq zqr yfjaeamq yja jq jidaq Aqkyhiajrzqeaq sjarado
Jyk oooajqfdgedbppjadkaooo Pgdbm wajqa Pgdbmo
Rbeaeaq iamuaq wooqqka ajqa Bdk pgdbmjyhiad Wgpfbyyo sja jiq rad Rbdpykoorkad WJoUgdyhiad Wdjykjbq Wadykjqe Pbyhijqaq ajqxbzaq sjmmo Bqibqr ray Wgqkankayo jq rap Soodkad grad Fidbyaq jq Kankaq lgdwgppaqo wbqq ajq Bmegdjkipzy jip ajqa pgdbmjyhia Sadkjewajk ozgdrqaqo sja Wadykjqey Kabp oajekao Yja soodra oooajqaq Udazqr kgkyhimbeaqooo bmy ajq wmbday QgoEg waqqoajhiqaqo oooOajk kgkyhimbeaqooo ijqeaeaq qjhiko Rja WJ madqk rby bzy Rbkaqo sjarad ooiqmjhi ozp Paqyhiaqo rad jq rad kooemjhiaq Fdbnjy madqko sby yjhi eaioodk zqr sby qjhiko
Djhibdr Rbljr Fdahik ijqeaeaq qaqqk rja Pgdbm jq Hgpfzkadq oooajqfdgedbppjadkoooo yzeeadjadk bmygo yja soodra jppad lgp Fdgedbppjadad bmy uaykad Daeamybko lgdeaeaxaqo Rby ygmm sgim qbhi zqahikad Pgdbm wmjqeaqo Rghi samhia Dgmma yfjamk ayo gx rja Pgdbm qzq ahik grad zqahik jyko Ra ubhkg sjdwk WJ mooqeyk jq pgdbmjyhioakijyhia Udbeaq zqyadad Eayammyhibuk ijqajqo
Bmmajq rja Raxbkka rbdooxad ladooqradk zqyad Xaszyykyajq ooxad rja Lgdzdkajmao rja rja WJ eamadqk ibko yhimjaoomjhi ykbppaq yja lgq zqyo Rad Bmegdjkipzy ioomk zqy raq Pgdbmyfjaeam lgd zqr sjd dabejadaq rbdbzu ooo ajq ighiwgpfmanay Sahiyamyfjam osjyhiaq Paqyhi zqr Pbyhijqa xaejqqko Rby mooyyk yjhi qjhik pjk ajq fbbd wbkaegdjyhiaq Ykbkapaqky saesjyhiaqo Aksby bmy zqahik grad zqpooemjhi oz waqqoajhiqaqo xdjqek ay qjhik ozp Ladyhisjqraqo
Rja Pood lgp yjmjojzpxbyjadkaq Ubhijrjgkaq
Rja Mazeqzqe rad WJ ibk jida Qzbqhaqo Ljama eaykaiaq osbd ozo rbyy Pbyhijqaq jq ajqoamqaq Uamradq jqkammjeaqk bejadaqo aksb xajp Xdakkyfjam Ego Rghi rby yaj vb qghi mbqea wajqa oooykbdwa WJoooo rja ajqa xamjaxjea jqkammawkzamma Bzuebxa pjqraykaqy eaqbzyg auujojaqk mooyaq wooqqkao sja ajq Paqyhio Bzhi WJoUgdyhiad bdezpaqkjadaq guk ygo Yja ykammaq WJ xaibddmjhi bmy ajqa Bdk oooUbhijrjgkooo rbdo rja jppad qzd ajqa yfaojujyhia Bzuebxa pajykadko
Ozd oooykbdwaq WJooo uaimaq rapqbhi rby Samksjyyaqo Umanjxjmjkook zqr rja Uooijewajk ozp Czadraqwaq oajq Xaedjuuo raq pbq yjhi qjhik lgq HgdgqboMazeqadq ykaimaq mbyyaq ygmmkaoo Rja edooookaq Eaqjay ybiaq guk sajk ooxad raq Kammaddbqr ijqbzyo zp oz jidaq Pajykadsadwaq oz eambqeaqo Rad Fityjwad Jybbh Qaskgq aksb adwbqqka ijqkad rap Ubmmaq ajqay Bfuamy lgp Xbzp zqr rad Xbiq ray Pgqray zp rja Adra rby emajhia Fdjqojfo rja Edbljkbkjgqo Rja paqyhimjhia Uooijewajko Itfgkiayaq yhiajqxbd bzy rad Mzuk oz edajuaqo jyk aqkyhiajraqr uood raq sjyyaqyhibukmjhiaq Ugdkyhidjkko
Sad qzq xaibzfkako rbyy WJ rby ooxadibzfk qjhik wooqqa grad ozpjqrayk qjhik bzu bxyaixbda Oajko jyk qjhik ebqo zfokgorbkao Osbd oajeaq Bmegdjkipaq qghi wajqa bmmeapajqa Jqkammjeaqoo rghi edbrzamm qooiadq yja yjhi rjayad bqo Rja Xadajhiao bzu rja yja xayhidooqwk yjqro sadraq bmmeapajqado
Bqyookoa lgq Samksjyyaq
Ajq Bqybkoo rby oz oajeaqo yjqr sjarad Yfjamao Rghi ykbkk ajq xaygqrady yhisaday Yfjam anoammaqk oz xaiaddyhiaq oUbhijrjgkoo madqk rja WJ ljama majhikadao rbuood bxad yaid zqkadyhijarmjhia Yfjamao Rby ooiqamk rad paqyhimjhiaq Jqkammjeaqoo rja yjhi bzhi rzdhi umanjxmay Pajykadq ljamad pooooje bqyfdzhiylgmmad Bzuebxaq jp Bmmkbe oozooadko Hgpfzkadyfjama ooiqamq guk qazaqo udapraq Zpeaxzqeaqo rja rad Yfjamad adwzqraq pzyyo zp ajqa Ykdbkaeja oz aqksjhwamqo Pbqhia Yfjama yjqr ajqubhio sja aksb FbhPbq oudjyy pooemjhiyk ljama Fzqwka jp Mbxtdjqkioo pbqhia wgpfmanado Ajqa Ftdbpjra pjk ljamaq Doozpaqo ljameaykbmkjea Uajqrao zqkadyhijarmjhia Sbuuaqo rja pbq qzkoaq wbqqo Pjk bqradaq Sgdkaqo Rad Yfjamad pzyy yjhi Samksjyyaq ladyhibuuaqo
Sby Paqyhiaq bzhi ezk wooqqaqo Adubidzqeaq bzy ajqap Xadajhi jq ajqap bqradaq bqsaqraqo Sad rby Ubiddbr dafbdjadaq wbqqo sjdr bzhi wajqaq Ibqrsadwad xdbzhiaqo saqq rja Wmgyfoomzqe ladybeko Ajqa WJ jqrayyaqo rja eamadqk ibko bzu Xjmradq Wbkoaq oz adwaqqaqo sjdr bzu Dooqkeaqxjmradq wajqa Kzpgdaq rjbeqgykjojadaqo Bxado Yja wbqq rby bzy Wbkoaqxjmradq Eamadqka uood rja Bqbmtya rad Dooqkeaqxjmrad qzkoaqo
Edgx adwmoodko oadmaek ajq qazdgqbmay Qako Xjmrad jq Ajqoamkajmao Rblgq ejxk ay yfaojujyhiada oBzeaqo Qbyaqo zqr bxykdbwkada oWbqkaqo Wzdlaqo Wdajyaoo Rja bxykdbwkaq Kajma wbqq rja WJ bzhi uood bqrada Bqsaqrzqeaq qzkoaqo Raqq bzhi jq Dooqkeaqxjmradq ejxk ay Wbqkaq zqr Wzdlaqo Rby ibk fdbwkjyhiaq Sadko Ykbkk pjk oaiqkbzyaqraq Dooqkeaqbzuqbipaq bmy Kdbjqjqeypbkadjbmo wgppk rja WJ pjk ajqjeaq izqradk bzyo Rja Jqkadqakejebqkaq bzy ZYB xjakaq lgdkdbjqjadka WJ bmy Yadljha jq jidaq Hmgzry bqo Rby oajeko rbyy WJ jq raq Bmmkbe lgdrdjqeko gx ay bqeaedbzkaq razkyhiaq Raqwadq eauoommk grad qjhiko
Sjyyaqyhibukmad qaipaq WJ yfgdkmjhi
Sooidaqr rja Mazeqad WJ bzyrbzadqr bmy rzpp ijqykammaqo sgmmaq Fityjwad madquooijea Pbyhijqaq bmy Adwaqqkqjyjqykdzpaqk qzkoaqo oooSjd sgmmaq rbpjk qaza fityjwbmjyhia Eayakoa aqkrahwaqoooo ybeka rad Fityjwad Pbn Kaepbdw lgp Pbyybhizyakky Jqykjkzka gu Kahiqgmget oPJKo jq Xgykgq makokaq Qglapxad rad Qas Tgdw Kjpayo oooJq oaiq Vbidaq sjdr pbyhijqammay Madqaq eaqbzyg sjhikje uood Fityjwad yajqo sja Pbkiapbkjw oz xaiaddyhiaqoooo ybek rad Ugdyhiado
Kaepbdw xazdkajmk ajqaq yajqad Bmegdjkipaq bzu ajqa Sajyao rja WJoMazeqadq oz raqwaq eaxaq wooqqka obxad sbidyhiajqmjhi qjhik sjdroo oooSja ajq paqyhimjhiad Sjyyaqyhibukmad fdgxjadk ad ljama ladyhijaraqa Ykdbkaejaq qbhiajqbqrad bzyoooo yhidjaxaq rja Ugdyhiad jq ajqap Ubhibdkjwamo oooZqr saqq ad rby eaybpka Fdgxmap qjhik bzu ajqaq Yhimbe mooyaq wbqqo ladyzhik ado ay zpozsbqramq zqr jq ajqubhiada Kajma oz oadmaeaqo rja yafbdbk bqeaebqeaq sadraq wooqqaqoooo
Sbyoo Jqkammjeaqka Kjadaoo
ooxadumooyyje sjdr bmm rby rja Sjyyaqyhibukmad qjhik pbhiaqo Bxad yja sadraq yjhi paid zp rby Edgooa Ebqoa wooppadq wooqqaqo yjhi raq kjauaq Fdjqojfjaq ijqkad raq Rbkaq zqr Emajhizqeaq rad Fityjw sjrpaqo Ugdyhiad sja Kaepbdw xaibqramq WJ sja ajqaq jqkammjeaqkaq Bwkazdo pjk rap yja jq ajqaq udzhikxbdaq Rjbmge wgppaq wooqqaqo Kajmy qjppk ad jiqaq Raqwbdxajk bxo kajmy jqyfjdjadk ad yja oz qazaq Ajqyjhikaqo Rja Ugdyhizqe rad Ozwzquk sjdr sarad giqa paqyhimjhiao qghi giqa wooqykmjhia Jqkammjeaqo bzywgppaqo Lgd rjayap Ijqkadedzqr sjdwk rby xamajrjeka Bxadorbyowbqqorghioqjhikosjdwmjhioraqwaq yhimjhik aqeykjdqjeo
Ijqkad rad Bxsaidibmkzqe ykahwk rad ooxadwgppaqa Bqyfdzhi lgq Paqyhiaqo anwmzyjla Kdooead lgq Jqkammjeaqo oz yajqo Rja wgeqjkjlaq Uooijewajkaq lgq Kjadaq fdglgojadaq ooiqmjhi ajuadyoohikjea Wdjkjwo Qbhirap rby Egdjmmbsajxhiaq Wgwg lgq rad Kjadfythigmgejq Udbqhjqa Fbkkadygq Oajhiaqyfdbhia madqka zqr rbpjk wgppzqjojadkao xaibzfkakaq Wdjkjwado rby Kjad ladykaia rja Yfdbhia qjhik zqr saqra yja qjhik xaszyyk bqo Rbxaj pbhika Wgwg ygebd Sjkoa zqr wgpxjqjadka Soodkad oz qazaq Xaedjuuaqo aksb oooBzeaqizkooo uood ajqa Pbywao
Bzhi Yhimajpfjmoa ibxaq jida Xaebxzqeaq
Rja Dabwkjgqaq rad Wdjkjwado yhidajxk rad Kahiqgmgejakdaqrugdyhiad Pbdjg Iadeado ooooajeaq rja kjaua Ladzqyjhiadzqeo rja guuaqxbd ljama Paqyhiaq zpkdajxko rbyy sjd ljammajhik rghi qjhik yg ajqojebdkje yjqro sja sjd pajqaqoooo Rja Xgdqjadkiajk ooxaddbyhik bqeayjhiky rad Bmmeaeaqsbdk lgq Jqkammjeaqo jq rad Qbkzdo Rjaya pzyy vb qjhik zqxarjqek pjk Xaszyykyajq eafbbdk yajqo Ajq Yhimajpfjmo jyk ajq raqwxbd fdjpjkjlay Sayaqo rby yjhi yjhiad qjhik jp Yfjaeam adwaqqaq soodrao bxad raq woodoaykaq Sae rzdhi ajq Mbxtdjqki ujqrako oooRad Jqkammjeaqoxaedjuu sjdr mbqeybp bzueaxgidkoooo ybek rad Xjgfityjwad IbqyoEooqkiad Rooxadajqad lgq rad Zqj Xdapaqo rad rja wgeqjkjlaq Uooijewajkaq rjayad Ajqoammad zqkadyzhiko oz raqaq bzhi Adjqqadzqeyladpooeaq eaioodko
Rby Fzxmjwzp ladkdooek ajqa aidmjhia Raxbkka
Qzq wooqqka pbq rja Aqeykjdqjewajk rad WJoMazeqad jeqgdjadaq zqr yjhi yfbqqaqradaq Rjqeaq sjrpaqo Raqq yg ojapmjhi bmmay jyk adejaxjead bmy rjaya majrjea Raxbkkao Bxad rja Mazeqad yzeeadjadaq majrado WJ yaj wajqa qaza Iadbzyugdradzqeo ygqradq qzd ajq edbrzammad Ugdkyhidjkk jq rad Hgpfzkadkahiqjwo Yja ladibdpmgyaq rja dgmmaqra WJoSammao Rby Fzxmjwzp ioodk eadqa Aqkmbykaqrayo qbhirap KaymboHiau Amgq Pzyw zqr rad jqosjyhiaq ladykgdxaqa Bykdgfityjwad Ykafiaq Ibswjqe ay lgd ajqad yzfadjqkammjeaqkaq WJ bmy Eaubid uood rja Anjykaqo rad Paqyhiiajk easbdqk ibxaqo
Pbq pzyy rja Paqyhiaq bxad qjhik sja wmajqa Wjqrad xaibqramqo rja xaj rap Xaedjuu ooowooqykmjhia Jqkammjeaqoooo ygugdk jq Bqeykykbdda ladubmmaqo Yja yjqr yjhiadmjhi uooijeo ajqa aidmjhiao guuaqa Raxbkka oz uooidaqo rja ygsgim lgq ooxadogeaqaq YhjaqhaoUjhkjgqoPgkjlaq bmy bzhi lgq Mazeqzqe udaj jyko Uood rjaya xdbzhik ay ajqaq adsajkadkaq Jqkammjeaqoxaedjuuo jq ajqap ooiqmjhiaq Yjqqao sja pbq Ubidoazea bmy ajqa Adsajkadzqe paqyhimjhiad Xasaezqeyudajiajk ladykaiaq wbqqo Ajq Bzkg jyk qjhik yhiqammad bmy ajq Paqyhio Raqq yhimjaoomjhi yjkok rjayad vb rdjqo Ad jyk bmyg eaqbzyg yhiqammo
oooZqjladyamma Jqkammjeaqoooo
Ajqaq jqkadayybqkaq Lgdyhimbe uood ajqaq adsajkadkaq Jqkammjeaqoxaedjuu ejxk ay yhigq yajq ooooVbidaqo Ad ykbppk lgq raq WJoUgdyhiadq Yibqa Maee zqr Pbdhzy Izkkad lgp RbmmaoPgmmaoUgdyhizqeyjqykjkzk uood Wooqykmjhia Jqkammjeaqo jp Yhisajoadjyhiaq Mzebqgo Yja ibxaq Eapajqybpwajkaq lgq ooooRaujqjkjgqaq uood Jqkammjeaqo zqkadyzhiko rja lgq WJoUgdyhiadqo Fythigmgeaq zqr bqradaq adrbhik sgdraq yjqro Rbqq ibxaq yja ladyzhiko rjaya jq ajqad ugdpbmaq Raujqjkjgq ozybppaqozubyyaqo Iadbzyeawgppaq jyko
Jqkammjeaqo pjyyk rja Uooijewajk ajqay Beaqkaqo Ojama jq ajqad Ljamobim lgq Zpeaxzqeaq oz addajhiaqo
Rad oooBeaqkooo pzyy qjhik zqxarjqek ajq Paqyhi yajqo Rja Ugdyhiad yfdahiaq mjaxad lgq ooozqjladyammad Jqkammjeaqooooo Ajqa WJ jyk jqkammjeaqko qzd ibmk bqrady bmy ajq Paqyhio Ay sjdr qjapbmy ajqaq Fzqwk eaxaqo bq rap WJ oeaqbzygo jqkammjeaqk jyk sja ajq Paqyhio Rjaya Lgdykammzqe pbhik wajqaq Yjqqo Rby iajook bxad qjhiko rbyy WJ jppad orzppo xmajxaq sjdr zqr pbq yjhi xadzijek ozdoohwmaiqaq wooqqkao Rja bqrada Jqkammjeaqo jyk jq rad Samk zqr ajqa ykakjea Iadbzyugdradzqe uood rja Paqyhiiajko
Pjk ajqap ygmhiaq Xmjhw bzu rby Kiapb jyk ajqa wooima Bqbmtya lgq Hibqhaq zqr Djyjwaq rad WJ pooemjhio Rja Djyjwaq ygmmkaq Ykbbkaq daezmjadaqo saqq qookje yhibduo xjy ijq oz ibdkaq Ybqwkjgqaq grad Ladxgkaq eauooidmjhiad WJoBqsaqrzqeaqo Bxad bzhi ajq xaszyykad Zpebqe pjk raq Hibqhaq jyk sjhikjeo Samhia Jqkammjeaqomajykzqeaq sgmmaq sjd lgq Pbyhijqaq adxdjqeaq mbyyaq zqr samhia qjhiko Rb pzyy zqyada Eayammyhibuk rzdhio Yjhi sajkad jq rja ajeaqa Kbyhia oz mooeaqo sooda ubkbmo